In an interview on Newstalk 107.9 with hosts Neal Larson and Julie Mason, Judge Steven Boyce discussed his bid for reelection and the principles guiding his work on the bench. Boyce, who serves as the district judge for Madison, Fremont, and Teton counties, is currently facing a challenge for his seat from Bonneville County Prosecutor Randy Neal.
Boyce highlighted his deep roots in Southeast Idaho, having grown up in Idaho Falls and practiced law in the region since 1996. After serving as a magistrate judge, he was appointed to the district court by Governor Brad Little in 2019 and subsequently won election in 2022. During the interview, Boyce emphasized his extensive experience, including his current role as the Administrative District Judge for the Seventh Judicial District, where he oversees operations across ten counties.
The conversation touched upon Boyce’s role in presiding over high-profile cases, such as the trials of Lori Vallow Daybell and Chad Daybell. While judicial canons prevent him from discussing specific case details, Boyce noted that his judicial philosophy is centered on upholding the Constitution and treating every litigant equitably. “My philosophy is to support the law, to uphold the law, to apply the law, and to do what I think the community expects of a judge in each one of my cases,” Boyce said.
Boyce also addressed the complexities of plea agreements, explaining that they are negotiated entirely by the prosecution and defense without judicial involvement. He noted that while he has the authority to reject inequitable agreements, he generally discourages “binding” plea deals because they limit a judge’s sentencing discretion. He suggested that if the state has a solid case, it should be prepared to go to trial rather than rely on bargaining.
Regarding potential legislative reforms, Boyce pointed out inconsistencies in mandatory minimum sentencing. He observed that while certain drug offenses carry mandatory minimums, violent crimes like rape do not, which he argued can create uncertainty and stress for victims. Boyce concluded by citing a recent Idaho State Bar survey where he received high scores from his peers, expressing gratitude for the professional support as he approaches the upcoming election.
