Bonneville County Prosecutor Randy Neal outlined his vision for the 7th District bench during a recent interview on Newstalk 107.9, emphasizing a need for systemic reform and stiffer sentencing for serious crimes. Neal, who is currently serving as prosecutor, is challenging incumbent Judge Steven Boyce for a four-year term in the upcoming election.
Speaking with hosts Neal Larson and Julie Mason, Neal explained that his decision to run for judge stems from a desire to improve a justice system he believes is currently failing victims. He argued that the regional legal system has become overly reliant on a “negotiation and plea agreement model.” While acknowledging the high volume of felony cases in Bonneville County, Neal contended that current sentencing trends for serious offenses often lack the deterrent effect the community expects.
“We have got to improve,” Neal said during the interview. “The community must have the system they want and the system they deserve.” He specifically addressed the challenges of prison capacity, noting that while Idaho often lacks space, judges in the 7th District should not use that as an excuse for leniency in cases involving violent crimes or the abuse of children. Neal suggested that the responsibility for managing population shifts should rest with the parole board rather than influencing initial sentencing decisions.
The conversation also touched on a recent Idaho State Bar survey in which Neal received lower marks from fellow attorneys regarding his temperament and legal knowledge compared to his opponent. Neal dismissed the survey results, citing a low response rate and suggesting that the feedback largely represents a defense bar that is opposed to his prosecutorial style. He framed his candidacy as a way to preserve the public’s role in selecting judges, noting that many judicial positions in Idaho are currently filled through appointments rather than contested elections.
Neal concluded the interview by asserting that his experience as a trial attorney qualifies him for the bench and that his primary goal remains the “recalibration” of the justice system to better align with public safety and legislative intent. The 7th District covers several counties in Eastern Idaho, including Bonneville.
